December 21
2011
December 21
2011
Overthinking It
by
Mark Lee
The author argues that Google Zeitgeist misuses the idea of a “zeitgeist” by presenting aggregated search behavior as the spirit of the times rather than as clues to broader cultural trends. Using Rebecca Black’s “Friday” as 2011’s top search, the piece revisits her rapid rise to fame and equally rapid loss of relevance, noting the personal fallout despite brief mainstream exposure. The author contends this kind of viral success is largely accidental and exceptional, while most top searches are driven by corporate marketing machines or major news events. Ultimately, the list reflects what people look up on Google, not a defining cultural mood.